Hello Worthington! Here's your recap of what happened at October 22's Architectural Review Board and Municipal Planning Commission meeting. Below are summaries of the commercial and institutional projects that directly impact our community.
City staff answer Issue 37 critics on merging Worthington's three development boards
Twelve days before the election, city planning staff closed the meeting by addressing what they called a misunderstanding about Issue 37, the charter amendment that would fold the Architectural Review Board, the Municipal Planning Commission and the Board of Zoning Appeals into one Municipal Development Commission. Staff told the board the proposal "truly is just a name change" and that "all the duties are staying the same," including the Architectural Review District and its design standards. The merged board would have seven voting members, all able to vote on every item. Today the two ARB-only members join the discussion of Planning Commission items but cannot vote on them. The city would have until December 31, 2028 to make the switch.
The case staff made was about who comes before these boards. Of Board of Zoning Appeals cases, 30 percent had already been through the ARB, and 85 to 90 percent of the applicants were residents rather than developers or businesses. All four items on the October BZA agenda had been to the ARB first. Because the ARB and Planning Commission meet together twice a month and Zoning Appeals once, a homeowner whose project needs both an appearance review and a variance can wait up to six weeks between hearings; one board could settle both questions at a single meeting. "We feel like it's going to be a benefit to our residents," one staff member said.
A board member said he supports the change but that a flyer "many of us have received" argues the opposite, that fewer eyes would see each project. "If we can show that it's 90% residential and not trying to sneak something through," he said, "that's a great message. But I don't think that's the message that's out there." Staff noted that the ballot question does not describe the merger; it asks whether to amend "various sections" of the charter. Because Issue 37 bundles the merger with the rest of the Charter Review Commission's recommendations, "if this doesn't pass, then none of the other changes get made to the charter." The Pulse's guide to Issues 35 through 38 has both sides, including the opposition's argument that one board means fewer resident decision-makers and fewer chances for public testimony.
Who sits on each board today
The Architectural Review Board and Municipal Planning Commission already meet together as one session, generally on the second and fourth Thursdays, with one agenda and one video, and the same five people sit on both. The Board of Zoning Appeals meets separately, generally on the first Thursday. In all, eleven volunteers fill the three boards, and Mikel Coulter is the only person on all three.
The membership of Worthington's three development boards as of October 27, 2026, from the city's board pages and the September 24 meeting minutes.
- Architectural Review Board (seven members): Mikel Coulter (chair), David Foust (vice-chair), Kathy Holcombe (secretary), Edwin Hofmann, Susan Hinz, Damien Healy and Ben Niebauer. Healy and Niebauer serve on this board only.
- Municipal Planning Commission (five voting members): Coulter (chair), Foust (vice-chair), Holcombe (secretary), Hofmann and Hinz. City Council Member Amy Lloyd also sits with the commission as Council's representative and does not vote.
- Board of Zoning Appeals (five members): Cynthia Crane (chair), Garrett Guillozet (vice-chair), Brian Seitz (secretary), Beth Benzenberg and Coulter, who holds the seat the charter reserves for a Planning Commission member. The other four members serve on no other board.
Within the shared ARB and Planning Commission session, members vote in whichever role an item falls under. The seven ARB members vote on design reviews. Five of them, as Planning Commission members, vote on planning items; the two ARB-only members can speak but not vote. Five Zoning Appeals members vote on variances and appeals at their own meeting. The new commission's seven voting members would vote on all three kinds of items, and its Council member would not vote.
Who has a vote on Worthington's three development boards today, and who would under Issue 37, as of October 27, 2026.
If Issue 37 passes, the Municipal Development Commission would have seven voting members and one non-voting Council member, and two of the seven would have to live in the Architectural Review District. Council appoints members of all three boards today, and would appoint the new commission's seven voting members. The amendment does not say what happens to current board members. The practical change falls mostly on Zoning Appeals, the only one of the three that meets separately: its four members who sit on no other board would not hold a seat of their own unless Council appoints them to the new commission.
Stay connected to what's happening in Worthington, Ohio.
In Other News
The comprehensive plan is adopted; the zoning rewrite is next. Staff reported that City Council adopted the Worthington Together comprehensive plan on Monday, October 19. One of the plan's recommendations is a rewrite of the city's planning and zoning code, which dates to 1971, and the city already has a request for proposals out for that work. Staff expect it to start in January or February 2027. The Planning Commission recommended the plan to Council on September 24.
A light agenda otherwise. The Municipal Planning Commission had no items, and the board's remaining applications were for individual homes, including three approved together without discussion on the consent agenda.
Upcoming Dates
- Monday, November 2, 7 p.m. — City Council meets at the Worthington Municipal Building, 6550 N. High Street. Council returns to the e-bike and e-scooter ordinance it postponed October 5, now weighing a youth rider-education class.
- Tuesday, November 3 — Election Day. Worthington voters decide four proposed City Charter amendments, Issues 35 through 38. The Pulse's breakdown and the Charter Review Commission page.
Was this recap useful? Forward it to a neighbor who'd want to know what's happening in Worthington — word of mouth is how the Pulse grows.
Thanks for reading this summary of the Architectural Review Board and Municipal Planning Commission meeting. You can watch the original full video here
Note: This recap focuses on commercial and institutional projects that affect the broader community. Individual homeowner applications, while important to those involved, are not included in this community newsletter.
