This story is part of Worthington Pulse's coverage of the October 26 Board of Education meeting. Start with the October 26 meeting recap.
The Board of Education got its first look on Oct. 26 at 21 policy updates from Neola, the policy service the district uses to keep its board policies current. The most-discussed change would let students ride e-bikes and scooters to school at any grade level, as long as the device is legal under Ohio law and they walk it once they reach school grounds. The package also adds language on AI note-takers and wearable cameras to the rules for recording parent-teacher and IEP meetings, sets up a way for athletes from neighboring districts to petition to join Worthington teams, and spells out that district money can't be used to campaign for a levy. No vote was taken; the policies are expected back for a second reading and vote on Nov. 9, or Nov. 23 if the board wants more discussion.
Vice President Stephanie Harless, who sits on the board's policy committee with President Amber Epling-Skinner, walked the board through the packet. Many of the updates simply keep the district in line with state law. The committee spent the most time on e-bikes, recording meetings and how the board fills an open seat.
E-bikes and scooters
Harless said the committee spent a lot of time on e-bikes because "it's all over the news," and that the goal was to protect students "in a way that, well, keeps them safe, but also doesn't infringe on their ability to get to and from school on devices that they may need."
What the draft says
Neola's model policy offered a range of versions, from a ban on all powered devices on school property to one allowing every class of e-bike at middle and high schools. The committee picked what Harless called "the most permissive option" and then trimmed it further.
What was cut:
No grade-level tiers. Neola's version would have kept personal transportation devices out of elementary schools entirely and required registration and a parent's sign-off for e-bikes at middle and high schools. The committee struck that language. Board member Kelli Davis confirmed with Harless that the district does not currently treat elementary, middle and high school differently.
No e-bike classes. The committee crossed out references to Class 1 and Class 2 e-bikes. "I don't think that we can expect anybody at a school to know what is a class one, class two, class three," Harless said. Neola recommended banning the faster Class 3 e-bikes outright. The committee left that out because state law already restricts them, including a minimum rider age of 16, and Harless said rules on device classes and age limits should be left "to the municipalities to deal with, not the administration."
No list of banned devices. The committee also struck a Neola list of things students could not bring without the superintendent's permission, including mopeds, hoverboards, one-wheels, modified e-bikes and devices with damaged batteries.
No campus speed limit. Neola offered an optional 10 mph limit on school property; the committee did not select it.
What stays:
- Students "should dismount their device on school grounds and walk their device to the rack," language Harless said came straight from the student handbook, and devices should be locked when not in use.
- Charging e-bikes, scooters or similar devices on school property is prohibited unless the superintendent approves it in writing.
- Devices may only be parked in designated areas and cannot block sidewalks, ramps, entrances, fire lanes or bus loading areas.
- The district takes no responsibility for theft, damage or injury, and breaking the rules can cost a student the privilege of bringing a device, along with discipline or a referral to police.
The policy says the board "in no way seeks to regulate" how students use these devices off school property.
Stay connected to what's happening in Worthington, Ohio.
Where school grounds end
Harless raised a question that came up after the committee met. Some students ride their devices from Thomas Worthington High School down to practice at "the flats at Thomas," and the dismount rule would technically cover that ride.
Superintendent Trent Bowers said the dismount language was written for the crowded minutes when everyone is arriving or leaving. On the ride to the flats, he said, "We wouldn't enforce that, right?" He described a similar stretch where students coming from Worthington Hills use a path into the Granby and McCord area; staff begin enforcing the rule once riders reach the parking lot.
Davis said the road down to the flats is a narrow two-lane drive with no sidewalks, and she was concerned about students riding it. Bowers said he wasn't sure any route was truly safe: "I don't know that I feel like there's any place where they're safe," since sidewalks and streets each carry their own risks.
Epling-Skinner floated a fixed zone, something like 500 feet from the front door. Board member Nikki Hudson said she was inclined to leave the language as written and let staff use their judgment when a safety problem arises. Harless agreed. The policy matches the handbook, she said, and gives the district room to enforce it if congestion at a big event becomes a problem. The board made no change.
A request for the cities to line up
Bowers asked board members to raise the issue when they talk with city officials. The district serves students in three different municipalities, he said, and if each sets its own rules, that creates a challenge for the district even though it isn't the one enforcing them. "We really need alignment in Worthington schools between our municipalities," he said. Harless noted that state legislation may be coming and that "the city of Worthington is looking at it, Columbus is looking at it." Worthington City Council's own e-bike ordinance is a separate track; council postponed its vote to Nov. 2.
Harless said the committee asked whether other districts have banned e-bikes entirely and was told some have. She said the district has to be careful about that: "We want every kid to be safe. We also want every kid to be able to get to school."
Recording meetings, and where AI fits
The committee also rewrote the policy on recording district meetings that involve students or parents, such as parent-teacher conferences and IEP and 504 meetings. The packet includes a new 20-page Neola artificial intelligence policy that would have replaced this one, but Harless said the committee "felt like it wasn't ready to bring before the board." (The district already has a board-level AI policy that received its first reading last spring. Harless said the Neola draft "will be much more comprehensive.")
Rather than wait, the committee kept the recording policy and pulled in language from the AI draft, because the policy said nothing about AI. The new opening says AI-enabled wearable cameras and AI transcription and summarization devices "present significant legal, privacy, and operational challenges for the schools environment." The core rules carry over: parents may audio record a meeting if they tell the district beforehand and use their own device, the district records the same meeting, video recording is prohibited, and covert recording is not allowed.
Board members pressed on several points:
- Legal review. Hudson asked whether the district still sends significant departures from Neola's language to its attorneys. Harless said this language came from Neola's own AI draft but that she had no objection to sending it to legal. Hudson said she would follow up after rereading it.
- Notice under Ohio law. Board member Sheena Costa Flowers asked whether requiring parents to give notice could be challenged, noting that Ohio lets anyone taking part in a conversation record it. Harless said the notice requirement isn't new and that she would find the guidance in the packet showing the district may require it.
- Who counts as a parent. Davis asked that the language cover guardians and foster parents. Harless agreed to make the wording consistent.
- Notice from the district. Davis asked whether the district tells families when it is the one recording. Bowers said recordings are rare. Expulsion hearings are one example, and the family is told on the recording because it becomes the legal record for an appeal. The committee added a line: "If the district records any meetings, verbal notice will be given." "I just think we give the same courtesy that we are requested," Davis said.
Stay connected to what's happening in Worthington, Ohio.
Accommodating student athletes from neighboring districts
A new policy puts in place a state law, known as the Student Athlete Mobility or SAM Act (Senate Bill 276), that lets a public high school student petition to join a team or activity at a neighboring district's high school when their own school doesn't offer it. Bowers said Ohio had already opened that door for hockey; two hockey players who live outside Worthington are set to play here, and one gymnast who lives in a district without gymnastics has asked to compete in Worthington under the new law.
The district added two details: petitions are due six weeks before a season starts, and a Worthington student must first seek a spot at the district's other high school before petitioning to join a team elsewhere.
Other changes
Filling an open board seat. When a board member leaves before their term ends, the remaining members appoint a replacement. The update gives them 45 days to do it instead of 30, which Harless said is a change required to stay in line with state law. Davis asked why the policy doesn't spell out how the board would find and interview candidates. Neola's optional language would have required advertising through the news media and other channels every time, so the committee left it out and plans to write a simpler process later.
"Students who are homeless." The board's homeless-students policy was updated to follow the federal McKinney-Vento Act, including students' right to obtain their records without an address. Hudson and Harless both objected to the title, which comes from the law. "You don't define someone based on the situation," Hudson said. Harless will retitle it; she said she prefers "students experiencing homelessness." Davis asked for a later update on how staff are trained under the act.
Staff outside activities. Three near-identical policies on outside activities of administrators, teachers and support staff will be combined into a single policy covering all staff in the operations section of the manual, with the old policy numbers pointing to it. Davis asked whether staff should be told about the move. Bowers said nothing is changing for staff and that a special notice could read like a warning.
Public money and levies. A new policy spells out that district funds cannot be used to support or oppose a candidate, levy or bond issue. The superintendent and treasurer can still publish factual information about the district's finances.
Credit card fees. Treasurer TJ Cusick said an update lets the district pay a convenience fee on its credit card, since "some vendors nowadays don't take a check anymore."
Compliance updates to policies on student athletics eligibility, youth organizations' access to students (Scouts, Boys & Girls Clubs and other federally chartered groups may recruit at school), medications, graduation credit, criminal background checks, public and student records, and relations with special interest groups.
What's next
Beyond the Nov. 9 vote, the policy committee is still working on the AI policy and plans to revisit the bullying policy and write a process for filling an open board seat in the coming months. Davis will miss the Nov. 9 meeting and thanked Epling-Skinner for scheduling the policy discussion for Oct. 26 so she could take part.
This is one of 2 Worthington Pulse stories from the October 26 Board of Education meeting recap.
